1. Write a policy shoppers can actually follow
A clear returns policy sells. Shoppers who can see exactly what happens if something doesn't fit are more willing to buy in the first place. It also saves you the back-and-forth when something does come back.
Go to Settings → Policies. If your Refund policy is empty, Insert template fills in a starter document with your store's name, email and address. Change every generic term to match how you really work: the return window, who pays return postage, how long refunds take and what can't be returned. Templates are drafting help, not legal advice.
Then turn on Enable structured return rules on the same page. Set a Return window (1–365 days), a Restocking fee percentage (0 for none) and any Final sale collections. These rules are enforced on every self-serve return request, but they are not copied into your policy text, so write the same details into the Refund policy too.
- Fill in the Refund policy and click Save.
- Enable structured return rules with the same window and fee.
- List final-sale collections, such as Sale or Clearance.
- Click View to read the policy on your storefront.
2. Let customers start the return themselves
Self-serve returns turn an email thread into a form. Turn on Let customers request returns from their account under Settings → Checkout → Customer accounts. Customers then see a Request a return button on their order status page, as long as the order is shipped and paid, not cancelled and still within your window.
Requests arrive on the order with the status Requested. Open the return and choose Approve return, with instructions on where to send the items and how to pack them, or Decline with a reason: Final sale, Return period ended or Other. The customer is emailed either way unless you turn it off.
For returns you arrange yourself, for example by phone, use Create return on the order's Returns card. You can add a restocking fee and a return shipping fee there, and both come off the refund later.
3. Receive first, refund second
Refunding before the parcel arrives is the most common returns mistake. Wait until the items are back and checked.
On the return, use Receive items: enter how many of each line arrived, tick Restock only for items that can be sold again, and choose the location they go back to. Then use Refund on the same return. The suggested amount is the units' value minus any restocking or return-shipping fee, which is only deducted on the first refund of a return.
Money moves according to how the customer paid. Card payments through Stripe and PayPal payments are refunded automatically through the provider. Cash, bank transfer, pay at the store, the local gateways and Point of Sale tenders are recorded for you to return yourself, and the screen tells you so.
- Check the returned items before you touch the refund.
- Receive items, restocking only what is sellable.
- Refund through the return so fees and quantities line up.
- For manual payment methods, return the money the same day and note how.
4. Handle refunds and cancellations outside a return
Not every correction needs a full return. For a missing item, a damaged parcel you don't want back, or a goodwill gesture, use Refund on the order's payment card. Enter quantities, a staff-only reason and the amount; partial refunds are fine. Tick Restock items only if stock really is coming back.
If you already refunded someone in your Stripe or PayPal dashboard, tick Record a refund made outside Lulu so the order matches reality without sending money twice.
Use Cancel order, under More actions, for an unfulfilled order that shouldn't go ahead. If it's paid, refund it in full first; cancelling is refused while money is left to refund. A shipped order can't be cancelled: refund it or create a return, and contact your carrier if you need the parcel back. There is no online exchange action: for an exchange, refund or return the original and create a new order, or a draft order, for the replacement.
5. Offer store credit or a gift card as an alternative
Some customers prefer to swap rather than wait for their money, and keeping the value in your store is good for you too. Offer it as a choice, never as the only option unless your policy says so.
Store credit lives on the customer's profile. Click Edit on the Store credit card and enter the new total balance: the number you type replaces the balance rather than adding to it, so add the old and new amounts yourself. Store credit is applied automatically at checkout when the customer is signed in to that account, in your store currency, as long as Let customers see and spend store credit is on.
A gift card works for customers who check out as guests or want to pass the value on. Create one under Products → Gift cards → Create gift card, choose the customer, add an internal note such as the order number, and send the code privately.
- Agree the choice with the customer in writing.
- Close the return without a money refund, so you don't refund and credit the same items.
- Add the credit to their profile, or issue a gift card with a note naming the order.
- Tell them how to use it: sign in for store credit, or enter the gift card code at checkout.
6. Learn from every return
Each return line carries a reason. Look at them monthly. If the same product keeps coming back as "too small" or "not as pictured", the fix is usually on the product page: a size guide, measurements, a photo of the item in use or a clearer description.
Fewer avoidable returns is the cheapest margin gain most stores can make.
Tips and tricks
- Put a one-line returns summary ("Free returns within 30 days" or whatever is true for you) near the add-to-cart button, linked to the full policy.
- A market can have its own Returns override. If a customer can't request a return that looks eligible, check the market their order belongs to.
- You can only cancel a return that hasn't received or refunded anything yet.
- Store credit isn't spent on orders in another currency, and gift cards only work in the currency they were issued in. Check before offering either to an international customer.
- Keep the "Send a notification to the customer" box ticked on refunds. The email explains how the money is coming back, which saves a follow-up question.
Checklist
- Refund policy written and published
- Structured return rules enabled with the same window and fee
- Self-serve returns turned on (if you want them)
- Approval instructions ready to paste
- Team agrees: receive and inspect before refunding
- Store credit and gift card options explained to staff
Explore the Lulu platform, compare packages, or ask the team about your setup.