← All guides

Marketing

Turn first-time buyers into regulars with loyalty points and tiers

Design a points program and tiers you can afford, tell customers it exists, and follow up after the first order so the second one comes sooner.

Smiling regular customers chatting with a shopkeeper as he hands over their groceries
Photo by Kampus Production on Pexels

1. Focus on the second order

Most new stores spend their energy finding new customers and very little on bringing them back. Yet a customer who has already received an order, liked it and trusted you with their card is the easiest sale you will ever make.

The gap between the first and second order is where loyalty is won or lost. Everything in this guide is about shortening it: a reason to come back (points), a reason to keep coming back (tiers) and a timely reminder (follow-up emails).

2. Design a points program you can afford

Go to Growth → Loyalty and switch the Points program on (it is off by default). Customers earn points when an order is paid, counted on the subtotal after discounts, and points are taken back proportionally on refunds.

Work out what a point is worth before you launch. With the defaults, customers earn 1 point per unit of currency spent and need 100 points for 1 unit of discount, which is about 1 % back, with a minimum of 500 points to redeem. Doubling the earn rate doubles the cost. Pick a rate your margin can carry on every order, not just on your best-selling item.

The Frequency bonus rewards repeat orders with bonus points on every Nth order, and it is on by default (200 points every 5th order) once the program is on. It rewards the habit you want without raising the everyday rate, but include it when you check the cost against your margin.

  1. Switch the program on and save.
  2. Set Points per [currency] spent.
  3. Set Points per 1 [currency] of discount and the minimum to redeem.
  4. Check the frequency bonus (on by default) and adjust or switch it off.
  5. Calculate the effective percentage back and check it against your margin.

3. Use tiers to reward your best customers

Tiers give your best customers something to keep. Bronze is the base tier at 1×. Silver and Gold have a minimum number of points earned over the last 12 months and an earn multiplier (by default 1,000 points at 1.25× and 5,000 points at 1.5×).

Set the thresholds from your own numbers: Silver should be reachable for a regular customer within a year, and Gold should feel genuinely exclusive. Tiers are recalculated whenever an order is paid, refunded or adjusted, and the multiplier on an order uses the tier the customer held before that order.

4. Tell customers the program exists

A loyalty program nobody knows about changes nobody's behaviour. Once it's on, a widget on the customer account page shows each member's balance and tier. Go further than that.

Mention points on product pages and in the cart ("Earn points on this order"), send one email campaign announcing the program to all subscribers, and add a line about it to your order confirmation. With the LoyalLane Rewards app you can also publish a public /rewards page and add a Rewards catalog of up to 20 rewards, such as free shipping or a gift card, each with its own points cost.

5. Follow up after the first order

Build a segment of first-time buyers under Customers → Segments (number_of_orders = 1, plus email_subscription_status = 'subscribed' for marketing email). Send this segment something useful a couple of weeks after they buy: how to care for the product, how others use it, what goes well with it, and a reminder of their points balance.

Run the Order follow-up thank you flow in Growth → Automations once a week so every recent buyer hears from you. It covers orders from the last 7 days, so a weekly rhythm reaches everyone once without duplicates.

  1. Create the first-time buyer segment.
  2. Write one evergreen follow-up campaign with a button to a related collection.
  3. Send it on a fixed schedule, for example every other Monday.
  4. Run the Order follow-up thank you automation weekly.

6. Look after your members

Scroll to Members in Growth → Loyalty to see each customer's tier, balance, lifetime points and last activity. Use Adjust to add goodwill points after a delivery problem or to correct a mistake, always with a reason.

Review the program every quarter: how many members redeemed, whether repeat orders rose, and whether the cost per redemption still fits your margin. Change the earn rate rarely and announce changes in advance; customers notice when a program becomes less generous.

Tips and tricks

  • Bonus points instead of a discount can be a cheaper thank-you after a late delivery, because the customer has to come back to use them.
  • Segment your top spenders (amount_spent above a figure that fits your store) and give them new products first.
  • Keep the redemption minimum low enough that a typical customer reaches it within two or three orders.
  • Refunds reverse points proportionally, so you don't need to claw back points by hand after a return.
  • Don't launch loyalty and a big discount in the same week. You won't know which one did the work.

Checklist

  • Points program on, with an earn rate checked against margin
  • Redemption value and minimum set
  • Silver and Gold thresholds based on your own customers
  • Program announced by email and mentioned on product pages
  • First-time buyer segment and follow-up campaign ready
  • Weekly Order follow-up run scheduled

Explore the Lulu platform, compare packages, or ask the team about your setup.

Put your next step into motion.